The fit of this sweater for me, at least right out of the package, is perfect. Roomy - I can wear a shirt under it - but not TOO loose and baggy. I wear a size 12 and ordered size large.
I love sweaters in the winter time and have been disappointed in purchases from stores of all types for more than a decade. Unless it shrinks or unravels upon wear or laundering, I've not been able to find a sweater that I think might be as comfy and wearable as this one in 20 years, at any price. Perhaps I just got lucky.